Sophia Bush; Austin Nichols.Photo:Amanda Edwards/Getty; Rodin Eckenroth/Getty

Sophia Bush; Austin Nichols

Amanda Edwards/Getty; Rodin Eckenroth/Getty

One Tree Hill’s Brooke Davis finally got her happy ever after with former bad boy Julian Baker, but the romance was never actually meant to be.

On Monday’s episode of theDrama Queenspodcast,Sophia Bushrevealed the true backstory behindAustin Nichols, who played her on-screen husband, Julian, and what she was originally told Brooke’s fate would be.

Bush, 41, who dated Nichols on and off from 2006 to 2012, said that the show’s “boss”Mark Schwahnmade a “promise” to her that she and Nichols’ characters would “barely ever have scenes together” and  their relationship would “certainly never be romantic.”

“Oh my God,”Hilarie Burton Morganreplied at her friend’s revelation.

Fred Norris / The CW / Courtesy Everett Collection

ONE TREE HILL, Austin Nichols, Sophia Bush, ‘Asleep at Heaven’s Gate’, (Season 8, episode 801, aired Sept. 14, 2010)

Julian came on the scene as a former love interest of Peyton (Burton Morgan), causing turmoil in her relationship with Lucas (Chad Michael Murray). Bush said that he was slated to be “the bad boy movie producer super cool guy,” and “maybe break up” Peyton and Lucas, but his multi-season arc was never shared with the cast.

“There was a lot of apology from the boss that was like, ‘I had no idea this overlapped with your real life. How weird!’ And I was like, ‘Dude I’ve dated, like, three people in 10 years. What do you mean you had no idea? You’re my nightmare,’” Bush recalled of a conversation with Schwahn, whomboth sheand Burton- Morganhavepublicly accused of sexual assaultduring their time on the hit CW show.

Frank Micelotta/Getty

The cast of “One Tree Hill”, Hilarie Burton, Chad Michael Murray, Sophia Bush, Bethany Joy Lenz, and James Lafferty on stage during “TRL BreakOut Stars Week” on MTV’s Total Request Live held on January 16, 2004 at the MTV Times Square Studios in New York City.

In Bush’s opinion, Schwahn “essentially emotionally castrated Julian and made him into a nerd who didn’t know how to give a high-five and who had a 6-year-old be his best man ‘cause he had no friends,” Bush said, referring to Nathan (James Lafferty) and Haley’s (Bethany Joy Lenz) son Jamie (Jackson Brundage).

“Just wild,” Burton Morgan said of the sequence of events that led to Brooke marrying the former Hollywood producer in season 7 of the show. (They later welcomed twins together in the series finale.)

“Wild," Bush said of the storyline. “And we all were like, ‘What is happening?’”

Sophia Bush and Austin Nichols in season 8 of ‘One Tree Hill’ (2010).Fred Norris / The CW / Courtesy Everett Collection

ONE TREE HILL Sophia Bush, Austin Nichols, ‘Darkness on the Edge of Town’, (Season 8, episode 811, aired Dec. 7, 2010)

Now, though, both actresses reflect fondly on Nichols and remain good friends with him.

“I really have enjoyed knowing Austin all these years at this point because he’s a wonderful actor, he’s really f—ing fun, he’s great at like extracurricular stuff,” Burton Morgan praised.

“He’s perfect,” Bush added. “We’ve all realized that in the way that we thought so many of our sweet male costars on this show were like the little brothers we were gonna have to rear — like, he is. And we love him. We’re family, we love each other, that’s all.”

The long-running drama seriescelebrated the 20th anniversary of its premierein September, and several cast members took to social media to mark the occasion. Murray, 42, wrote in an Instagram Story, “If you’d have asked me back in 2003… Never in my wildest dreams would I’ve thought we’d still have this magical bond.”

Bush opted to take the moment to celebrate her decades-long friendships with Burton Morgan and Lenz, 42, amidst the then-ongoingSAG-AFTRA strike. “Not gonna mention the job that’s turning 20 today while our union is on strike,” she wrote onInstagram." So instead I’ll celebrate 20 years of female friendships being the ultimate love stories and the reclamation of our good, bad, ugly and beautiful through @dramaqueensoth."

Lenz shared a carousel of images from the show, writing in an Instagrampost, “This will always be my family. Thank you to everyone who made it possible 🙏”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

One Tree Hillcan be streamed in full on Hulu.

If you or someone you know has been a victim of sexual abuse, text “STRENGTH” to the Crisis Text Line at 741-741 to be connected to a certified crisis counselor.

source: people.com