When you purchase through links on our site , we may earn an affiliate commission . Here ’s how it works .
The Food and Drug Administration recently made a perhaps surprising good word : Do n’t consume raw flour .
The warning publish last week came in reception to an outbreak ofE. colithat has sickened at least 42 multitude in 21 states since December . The FDA tracked the outbreak to a batch of General Mills flour sold under the brand names Gold Medal , Gold Medal Wondra and Signature Kitchens , triggering a reminiscence .
Most people who record the good word in all likelihood already sleep together they were n’t supposed to eat cooky dough because of the raw eggs in it ( though people donꞌt always do what theyꞌre suppose to do ) . But the flour testimonial was flummoxing , particularly because of the FDA ’s explanation : Flour is a field food for thought , the way said in aJune 28 consumer update . If pathogens get into the pale yellow plants while they are grow in a force field — via wild beast waste , for example — they ’ll stay in through the milling process .
That advice makes sense . Except that multitude run through slews of field foods bare-ass . If naked as a jaybird flour is dangerous , what about a spinach salad or a pipe bowl of fresh strawberries ? Why has n’t the FDA declared all raw foods a no - go ? [ Top 7 Germs in Food That Make You Sick ]
Live Science verbalise with an FDA expert and an outdoor food safety researcher who had the answers . Bottom line : Yes , salad can make sickness , and garden truck has been link to many more outbreaks than flour . But the risk of illness from raw green groceries is considerably understood than the for the most part unquantified jeopardy from grains . And fruits and veggie are processed under the assumption that masses will rust them raw , whereas flour is n’t .
New awareness
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that virtually half of foodborne illnesses arecaused by produce . So why raise the red flag over flour ?
" We just want to leave consumers with the expert information to take step to reduce their risk , " say Jenny Scott , a senior consultant in the place of food safety machine at the FDA Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition . " The same thing happens when we have aproduce outbreak . "
But the ways that people traditionally use flour did influence both the timing and the depicted object of the testimonial . Typically , Scott told Live Science , people do n’t feed bare-ass flour in large quantity .
" Because people donꞌt call back of bare-assed flour as being a concern , that ’s one of the cause we ’re realize the effort to get the information out , " she enjoin . The risk of illness from in the raw flour is low , she said , but then , so is the risk from raw produce .
The current flour - related outbreak is the 2nd of two such outbreak in the past seven age . The earlier one wasa 2009 outbreakof another tune ofE. colicaused by Nestlé Toll House prepackaged biscuit dough , which — surprise , surprise — people were eating raw . Exhibiting a clear - eyed realism about human nature , Nestlé opt to initiate heating - process all of the flour in its raw cookie boodle .
Some recent alteration in consumer doings may explicate the appearance of this newest flour - have-to doe with eruption , Scott said . Some pizza shop , for example , have set off giving kids balls of rude dough to encounter with while they await for their meals . But also , improvements in epidemiology now let researchers to find and dog outbreaks that might have gone unnoticed in early eld , she said .
" It occur once , you think , ' Well , that ’s a fluke , not really an number , ' " Scott said . " It happens twice , you start thinking , ' Hmm , perchance there is something here . ' "
Known unknowns
nutrient safety expert are now aware of the flour risk , but are only beginning to understand it . Outbreaks touch to grow have been studied intensively for two 10 , starting with a massive irruption of transmission with the parasiteCyclosporain 1996 ( it finally was traced to raspberries imported from Guatemala ) . By comparison , there is n’t much data on the preponderance of pathogen in flour , say Ben Chapman , a prof of food rubber at North Carolina State University .
" Over 20 years , we have a pretty good savvy , or a better understanding , of fresh produce consumption , but when it comes to flour , we do n’t bonk , " Chapman told Live Science . " It ’s hard to make risk - direction decisions based on unknowns . "
No one really get it on how General Mills ' flour became contaminated , or if contamination is a widespread trouble among other brands . E. colican spread through animal fecal matter , so wildlife pooping in and around fields might be the culprit . But untreated irrigation water system could disseminate the bacteria , too , Chapman said , or there could be some sort of cross - contaminant during the milling process . No one knows how longE. colior other pathogens persist in juiceless foods like flour , he said .
" It ’s still relatively new for us to be looking at this as a community , " he say .
As for produce , which is currently responsible for far more outbreaks than in the buff flour , the FDA is making step on safety . The agency recently release a young Produce Safety dominion under the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act that need specific piss lineament guideline and examination for irrigation water system , rules for manure and compost use , and standards touch on to doer hygienics and equipment and dick . new sprouts , the culprit in 42 eruption between 1996 and 2014 , get limited attending under the raw regulation . [ Top 10 Science Buzzkills : study that Ruin Your Fun ]
Grains are n’t covered under the novel Produce Safety prescript , but both producer and regulators will likely be looking at ways to melt off the risk of taint , Chapman and Scott enounce . Widespread heat - treatment of flour seems unlikely at this breaker point due to the deficiency of infrastructure and technology to treat the grain supply , according to Scott .
But with huge grain - consuming ship’s company like Nestlé and General Mills linked to outbreaks , producers will be examining their supply chain and processing practice , Chapman said .
" It ’s bad business , being connect to outbreaks , " he enounce .
Original article onLive scientific discipline .
